Adhoc City/School Packet 2003 10-22-03 .sf,13
Cep`
United City of Yorkville
County Seat of Kendall County
EST.% 1836 800 Game Farm Road
CO Yorkville,Illinois 6056010 �J O Phone:630-553-4350
'eF NEMC: $. Fax:630-553-7575
AGENDA
AD-HOC TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE
Wednesday, October 22, 2003
7:00 P.M.
RIVERFRONT BUILDING
301 E. HYDRAULIC STREET
REVISED: 10/21/03
1. Minutes for Approval/Correction: August 20, 2003 and September 9, 2003
2. Technology Recommendation
3. Additional Business
Jim ,
United City of Yorkville
1°11County Seat of Kendall County
EST.eki 1836
800 Game Farm Road
Q 10 0 CQl) YorkvillePhone: , Illinois630-553-4350 60560
J
Fax:630-553-7575
ELLE \
AGENDA
AD-HOC TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE
Wednesday, October 22, 2003
7:00 P.M.
City Conference Room
REVISED: 10/20/03
1. Minutes for Approval/Correction: August 20, 2003 and September 9, 2003
2. Technology Recommendation
3. Additional Business
United City of Yorkville
County Seat of Kendall County
EST.% _:_w__Liiimi1836
800 Game Farm Road
■C I
Cl) Yorkville, Illinois 60560
O 11 o Phone:630-553-4350
.m�a
S._ rm o.` v�� Fax:630-553-7575
4LE %\'
AGENDA
AD-HOC TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE
Tuesday, October 22, 2003
7:00 P.M.
City Conference Room
1. Minutes for Approval/Correction: August 20, 2003 and September 9, 2003
2. Technology Recommendation
3. Additional Business
Page 1 of 4
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE DRAFT
AD HOC TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE MEETING
WEDNESDAY,AUGUST 20, 2003
6:30 P.M.
In Attendance:
Alderman Marty Munns—Chairman Finance Director Traci Pleckham
Alderman Larry Kot Police Office Supervisor Molly Batterson
Alderman Rich Sticka Mayor Art Prochaska(arrived at 6:45)
Alderwoman Wanda Ohare Administrator Tony Graff(arrived 7:05)
Guests:
Wally Graff- Software Performance Specialists, Inc. (SPS)
Andy Clemens- Weblinx
APPROVAL/CORRECTION OF MINUTES
The minutes from the July 29, 2003 meeting were approved.
REVIEW PROPOSALS
The committee discussed the internet service proposals they received. They were also
reviewed by Wally Graff from SPS who is the city's current software consultant. Mr.
Graff stated that ICN is the most economical for the City. The drawbacks are that the
City would have to connect to the library and due to the Patriot's Act, any sites visited are
audited. Mr. Graff recommended the City get a T1 connection. This would eliminate
dial up lines and probably cost the same as what the City is currently spending.
Finance Director Traci Pleckham stated that the City currently has seven or eight dial-up
connections with AOL which is approximately $178.00/month along with twelve
telephone lines. She stated that she met with a representative of SBC and was told there
was a way to save up to $700.00/month based on reconfiguring telephone and modem
lines.
Also discussed was the use of Comcast cable lines. Mr. Graff stated that he spoke with
Comcast and they are willing to provide the City with free cable modem. The drawbacks
to this method are: it is meant to have only a single connection so it does not route to
multiple users however a router could be used,the band width in not guaranteed,the
download is slower and multiple users slow the system. Everyone can still receive e-mail
and there would not be a need for multiple phone lines. The committee discussed using
Comcast short term while saving up for a Ti line.
Andy Clemens from Weblinx stated that he has done consulting for other communities
li and Montgomery and Oswego use DSL. The Oswego PD is changing to a T1 line soon
to join in a countywide share program which the Yorkville PD hopes to join in the next
year and a half.
Page 2 of 4
Connecting all the City's buildings was discussed. Mr. Graff recommended a Ti
connection between remote locations. This would cost$190.00 to $230.00/month per
line. Mr. Graff did not recommend wireless (microwave) between locations because
hackers can easily get into this system. Mr. Graff pointed out that not only is there a
monthly cost for this but also the initial expense for equipment. He stated that it would
cost approximately$12,000.00 to $15,000.00 for equipment and labor to connect the
locations with a Ti line. The committee went over SBC's handout which demonstrates
how the locations can be linked and the equipment needed to do this. The cost for SBC's
internet access will be $725.00/month for the City Hall connection and either
$1,000.00/month or$1,107.20/month(depending of the length of the contract)for the
remote locations. Novacon proposed a monthly charge of$595.00 plus$950.00/month
for the remote locations. They offered a one-year contract and provide a router for
internet connections which is a savings of$800.00 to $900.00. Mr. Graff felt Novacon's
offer was the better proposal. Mr. Graff went over the possible extras such as the cost for
routers, switches at remotes, firewalls, and installation. He stated that he could put
together the costs.
Alderman Kot asked if this system would accommodate the City having its ordinances,
agendas, minutes, etc. on its website. Mr. Clemens stated that this system would work.
Mayor Prochaska noted that this information is available on the City's website and the
public will not have access to the City's network.
The committee discussed the ability to add to the system in the future. Mr. Graff stated
that the system is not limited in size.
Alderwoman Ohare asked what would be lost by changing to a different system. Mr.
Graff stated that there would be no change to the equipment at the City Hall so no
investment would be lost. He did recommend against using Microsoft Exchange because
this would necessitate having an IT employee on staff because it needs constant
tweaking. Mr. Graff and SPS could oversee the administration of the system for far less
than hiring a new employee.
The committee discussed the availability of DSL. Chairman Munns stated that he
inquired about this for his home and was told by SBC it was months away from being
available in the area. Administrator Graff stated that there is not enough space in the
Ameritech building to provide DSL so it will not be available until the building is
expanded.
Chairman Munns stated that the committee needed more information so he asked Finance
Director Pleckham to work up the costs involved for the next meeting on September 2,
2003 (before the COW meeting). He asked her to analyze Ti lines throughout the City's
buildings including the setup of the infrastructure and a breakdown by building. He also
asked her to chart the savings between proposals.
Page 3 of 4
WEB SITE UPDATE
Andy Clemens from Weblinx reported that the biggest challenge with the website is what
to do with the home page. His target date for having the site up is Friday, August 22,
2003. The committee discussed the home page and made suggestions such as having the
City flag waving on it and they suggested making frequent changes to the home page in
order to keep it interesting. Mr. Clemens stated he would look into that. Alderman
Sticka noted that someone would need to make these "frequent"changes. Mayor
Prochaska stated that he would like to see the site changed monthly so as to not tie up
personnel.
They discussed having the Council's e-mails forwarded to their home e-mail. Mr.
Clemens stated that this could be arranged.
The consensus of the committee was to launch the website before the Riverfront Festival.
LAPTOPS FOR COUNCILMEN
The committee discussed providing laptops for the Council in order to eliminate
paperwork. Administrator Graff noted that not all paperwork is generated by the City so
someone would have to scan them. Mayor Prochaska stated that the City could ask for
hard copies of documents along with them on a disk. The cost of laptops was discussed.
Mayor Prochaska had a Dell catalog which listed them beginning at $699.99. It was
suggested that communities such as St. Charles and Galesburg who are already using
laptops be contacted for input. Administrator Graff stated that he spoke with a former
Alderman with the City of Aurora who stated that the Council was given meeting packets
on disk to download on to laptops and 90%of the Council did not use the laptops. He
stated that Aurora did not have a comprehensive plan to implement the system and also
they could not network with other city departments.
Chairman Munns suggested that the committee think about how they would use laptops
and bring their ideas back to the next meeting. Administrator Graff stated he would start
researching E-Government and bring the information to the committee.
ELECTRONIC RECORD KEEPING
Administrator Graff reported that the file rooms for the Clerk's Office and the Police
Department are at capacity. He would like to look at budgeting Laser Fiche into next
year's budget. The cost of the system last year was around $15000.00 to $18,000.00. He
stated that staff would be talking with the company in the future to get an updated price.
This system allows documents to be scanned in order to be stored and create a database.
Mayor Prochaska suggested that the City may want to have Laser Fiche create the
database because it is time consuming. The committee discussed if the pros and cons of
the system.
It was decided to get cost information and to bring this back to another meeting for
further discussion.
Page 4 of 4
ADDITONAL BUSINESS
Alderman Kot reported that there is a virus being sent from an address of elburn.il.us. He
thought it was a government document so he opened it and his computer got the virus.
There was no further addition business so the meeting was adjourned at 8:00 P.M.
Minutes respectfully submitted by:
Jackie Milschewski, City Clerk
rage l or•
UNITED CITY OF YORKVILLE DRAFT
AD HOC TECHNOLOGY COMMITTEE MEETING
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9„2003
6:50 P.M.
In Attendance:
Alderman Marty Munns—Chairman Finance Director Traci Pleckham
Alderman Larry Kot Administrator Tony Graff
Alderman Rich Sticka
Alderwoman Wanda Ohare
Guests:
None.
Chairman Munns announced that Finance Director Traci Pleckham needed more time to
complete the cost analysis for T1 lines. There is not enough information for the
committee to have a discussion. He cancelled the meeting and stated he would contact
the committee members regarding a new date.
The meeting was adjourned at 6:55 P.M.
Minutes respectfully submitted by:
Jackie Milschewski, City Clerk
®,�1D CO).141
° United City of Yorkville Memorandum
iiftion�
� 800 Game Farm Road
EST. ¢� 1836
Yorkville, Illinois, 60560
p la Telephone: 630-553-4350
0
c-ty
�? Fax: 630-553-7575
!<CE % '
Date: October 14, 2003
To: Ad-hoc Technology Committee eil
From: Traci Pleckham - Finance Directo_4
CC: Mayor Prochaska, Tony Graff, Laura Brown, Molly Batterson
Subject: Technology Recommendation
On 09/15/03, staff, along with representatives from Software Performance Specialists and
E2 Technologies, met to discuss the immediate and long-term arrangements for
technology connections for City Hall, and other City offices. The solutions included; the
most technology advanced solution, most economical, and the ability to stage the
technology over more than one year.
The most technology advanced solution because of growth and connection would be a
point to point T-1 connection. However this would also be the most costly.
The most economical solution would be a DSL connection and VPN to connect the remote
locations. However this is also the most unreliable.
The compromise would be fiber optic connection between City Hall, Library and Beecher
Community Center. This would allow the connection to the Library's T-1 with using the
least amount of hardware. This would allow for a lateral connection and one single port of
intra connection, requiring the least amount of firewalls and transceivers. This also allows
for an immediate T-1 connection, and allows the City to budget and explore point to point
connections at a future date.
The fiber optic connection also allow for phone connection using the same cable. This
would allow for one-point connection of phone calls, and the ability to transfer between
buildings without using an outside line. Connection would be about $5,000 plus trenching
work. This may not include hardware upgrades.
There were two concerns that need further exploring;
The Patriot Act - Heritage Trail Audit and filtering ability
The ability to use the ICN connection.
After exploring the ICN and the audit and filtering abilities, the members in attendance
would recommend the following actions to complete the City Hall and City Office
connections for high speed technology connections:
Phase One — RFP for fiber optical connections between Library, City Hall and Beecher
Community Center. To include Firewall and transceivers, installation of the cable by
trenching between the buildings. This connection would allow for cable connection for use
by computers and phones.
For Public Works, and the Riverfront building, explore the use of DSL connections and
purchase a VPN connection for access into the main server.
Upon approval to proceed with Phase One, staff will then complete the RFP process
and bring results to the next Ad-Hoc Tech committee meeting. Staff is also
requesting that funding for Phase One be included on the "project list"for the 6-
month revised budget.
Staff also recommends the following future phases, to be re-visited as the City's
technology needs progress:
Phase Two — Explore a separate T-1 connection for City Hall and Beecher Community
Center.
Phase Three —when T-1 connections are available for remote sites.